6 Comments
User's avatar
Bill Hiatt's avatar

I think Tolkien himself would be impressed by this analysis.

Expand full comment
maryh10000's avatar

That has to be one of my favorite, if not THE favorite, quote from LOTR. "I pass the test. I will diminish ... and remain Galadriel." I will not trade my soul for power.

Expand full comment
Boflys's avatar

Well done

Expand full comment
Contarini's avatar

That passage brings tears to my eyes.

Clinging to the fading world is death, and Galadriel had the wisdom and strength not to do it.

Expand full comment
Eric's avatar
Oct 2Edited

Galadriel is the greatest of the elves, I agree. But it is not for passing the test, because that comes second. First, Galadriel learned the lesson that all in Arda fades and withers except for the glory and power of Eru Iluvatar. It is learning that lesson, that she is a child, not god, that enables her alone of all the elf lords to pass the test.

Expand full comment
The Portuguese Lady's avatar

Very interesting analysis.

Expand full comment